Probably the best movie that could be made from the book. All the actors are good - Viggo it goes without saying, and I was happy Smit-McPhee acquit himself nicely (happy because he definitely seems a good fit for the Right One remake now) - and the film is beautifully shot. Death and squalor never looked so lovely.But where McCarthy's astonishing prose tipped the scales from merely being an intellectual exercise where these no-named symbols move around expressing concepts to feeling like so much more than only the parts of the sum, Hillcoat's not there as a film-maker to bridge that gap visually, emotionally. That's not really as big a slam on Hillcoat as it might seem - McCarthy's such a good writer I don't know who could bridge that gap, really. Noble, beautiful, well pieced together, but ultimately thwarted. Read the book.
.
Posts
3 comments:
the road is playing NOWHERE
its almost like the studio is trying
to kill it. The revenues from last
weekend are tiny. What gives?
I'd have to double-check it but I do think it's getting the slow platform type release, crazycloud, where it's just opening in a few markets at first and branching out from there. I think. I could be wrong - who the fuck knows with the Weinsteins?
Oh and I checked IMDb before publishing this and IMDb just listed Thanksgiving as the date with no specifics on it opening in just a few cities or what, so I don't know. Hrm. Effin' Weinsteins.
When I saw the action packed theater preview I thought -- that is not the movie that I pictured in my head when I read the book.
Post a Comment