my new plaid pants: Which Is Hotter?

Thursday, May 07, 2009

James T. Kirk:
Shatner or Pine?

homeslaughter said...: Until Chris Pine gets his shirt ripped off on a green sky planet or goes all eye-liner-evil-twin, I have to stick with vintage Shatner.; 5:56 PM
J.D. said...: I voted Pine because I'm not old.; 6:01 PM
Jason Adams said...: One day we will all be dust, JD. But pretty pictures of us when we were young last forever!

That is to say we're not talking about Bill Shatner today. We're talking about him 40 years ago. And I'm on Team Shatner 100%. This Pine character has lovely eyes but has to prove himself in the long-run before he can dethrone Original Flavor Kirk.; 6:05 PM
Sibia Marie said...: I can't decide! I think Pine is hotter than Shatner BUT he still has to prove himself as Kirk.

I agree with homeslaughter about the ripping of the shirt. It looked like Zoe Saldana was attempting to do that on the cover of Entertainment Weekly. ;); 7:19 PM
Joe Reid said...: I'm with J.D. Even before Shat got all bloaty and alkie-faced, he still looked like it was on the way.; 7:38 PM
Ross said...: I went for Shatner. I think the voting is unfairly biased because of what he looks like now. But back in the day...; 11:06 PM
Dan said...: Hayden (new Dark Vader) looks like the new Capt. Kirk in this pic.
http://1.bp.blogspot.com/_5mxw-sYc_F0/SgPMFOtjsNI/AAAAAAAAffY/EmyexmlMEu4/s1600-h/hayden_lacoste.jpg; 12:06 PM